The pages of whatsapp groups and social media are heavily laden by repeated sightings, supported by congratulatory remarks, of isolated rarities. In my area, these have recently included a Pacific Loon (Gavia pacifica), a Common Eider (Somateria mollissima) and a Blue-winged Teal (Spatula discors) within the Bay of Gibraltar. To see them would have been easy for me, a matter of a short drive, but I have had no interest in doing so. In fact, I have driven past the sites where these birds are located several times and not bothered. I understand the excitement that such rarities elicit but, for me at least, they are mere anecdotes that show how far birds can stray away from their natural geographical range. That’s it.

Common Eider in the breeding grounds

I am also amazed at how little people read and how ready they are to report “the first” birds seen arriving. Only in the last day or two I have seen reports of the arrival of the first Barn Swallows (Hirundo rustica) to my area. People seem oblivious that they have been here in good numbers for a few weeks now, as readers of my 10,000 birds posts will know. These claims of extreme rarities or the first sighting seem to generate a flood of clapping emojis and “well dones”, which I find perplexing.

Barn Swallows resting during the northward migration

For me, the systematic approach to collecting bird observations is the basic stuff of ornithology. In that I include reports of birds seen in particular geographic regions, as some of the excellent accounts in 10,000 birds indeed do. In remote and under-watched places, these can provide the basis for improving our knowledge of birds, their status and distribution. Repeated, systematic, counts in the same sites are also of great value and they also help us clarify the “when” of bird arrivals and departures.

Alpine Swift

Have you noticed how few claims are ever made in such groups to the “last” bird to have left, say after the winter? The reason is that it is very easy to see an arrival of a bird when you haven’t been seeing it for a few months. On the other hand, you can only detect the last departures if you follow the population systematically. I, along with colleagues, have been following the winter roost of Crag Martins (Ptyonoprogne rupestris) for the past six winters. We have counted the birds weekly, sometimes twice each week. In these years, all the birds have been gone by mid-March but one year some remained until the first week of April. We only know this because we kept going back until our counts showed zero returns. The last counts tend to be very boring, as you know there’s only a handful left, but you have to keep going back. You won’t get any claps or likes in social media for this but that is not why we do it. We are doing ornithology.

Alpine Swift

So, this week, my systematic counts have shown, not the first one or two Barn Swallows of the year as has been claimed but, instead, a heavy passage of thousands of them coming in from North Africa and heading north. With them, more House Martins (Delichon urbicum) and Red-rumped Swallows (Cecropis daurica). And for those who like the “firsts” of the year, we were treated to swift royalty in the form of an Alpine Swift (Tachymarptis melba) coming in with the flow of hirundines. I wonder how long it will be before the “first” Alpine Swift gets reported!

Alpine Swift


Written by Clive Finlayson
Growing up in Gibraltar, it is impossible not to notice large birds of prey, in the thousands, overhead. That, and his father’s influence, got Clive hooked on birds from a very young age. His passion for birds took him eventually to the Edward Grey Institute of Field Ornithology at Oxford University where he read for a DPhil, working with swifts and pallid swifts. Publishing papers, articles and books on birds aside, Clive is also a keen bird photographer. He started as a poor student with an old Zenit camera and a 400 mm lens; nowadays he works with a Nikon mirrorless system. Although his back garden is Gibraltar and the Strait of Gibraltar, Clive has an intimate knowledge of Iberian birds but his work also takes him much further afield, from Canada to Japan to Australia. He is Director of the Gibraltar National Museum. Clive's beat is "Avian Survivors", the title of one of his books in which he describes the birds of the Palaearctic as survivors that pulled through a number of ice ages to reach us today.