On 6 October I came across an American Redstart in Edgewater, New Jersey, that seemed perfectly normal at first, when I was only viewing the bird’s left side. It was foraging and even flycatching like any other redstart would. When I saw the bird’s right profile I realized something was wrong but it took me a couple of minutes to get a clear view and then I felt nothing but pity.
I know that the late stages of conjunctivitis can look similar to how this bird looks but in this case it might be the result of an injury (though I could be completely wrong as I am far from expert on such matters). It was hard to believe my own eyes as I watched this bird forage, charge a House Sparrow, and act as if nothing was wrong with the entire right side of its face.
Anyway, expert readers, help me out here. Is this disease? An injury? Or is the problem not identifiable to cause? Whatever caused it I must say that this little bird showed more spunk with a major injury then I do when I have a cold.
Good luck, little redstart – you’ve got a long way to go and even longer odds then most migrant songbirds.
…
Poor little guy (or gal). I just saw a redstart on my fire escape recently, same coloring. I haven’t seen a red/black one yet.
It’s amazing how adaptable animals are.
I think that this is an injury. It seems like if it had house finch eye disease or conjunctivitis the area where it’s eye should be swollen and pink, whereas this bird’s eye area is going in, probably indicating that there is an empty eye socket there. It really is amazing how resilient birds are, but after all, they kind of have to be.
I share Nick’s thoughts on this one, Corey. I’m wondering about a sharp-shin’s talon. Migration is a mighty risky proposition. Releasing a one-eyed passerine is always a tough call. In an odd way, this brightened my day, that a flycatching, gleaning insectivore could make it and look that with it, having only one eye. Cool post. Godspeed, little redstart.
Thanks, Nick and Julie. Maybe I’m not as inexpert as I thought…
I have a baby Baltimore Oriole in the nest ready to fledge that looks like this … I am so worried for the little guy, I feel A whole lot better now too … Hoping to get some better pictures, Good luck little Guy <3