I don’t know what it is, but since I bought Dick Forsman‘s “The Raptors of Europe and Middle East” my interest in buzzards has gone through the roof. In fact it got so bad that when we bought a new car, my only decision criteria was whether it had a full glass panorama roof or not. Come to think of it, the cruise control comes in really useful when a buzzard is cruising over the Autobahn (much to my wife’s dismay).
And so there are few things that turn my head like a Common Buzzard (Buteo buteo) even though they are really, well, common. Not that my interest says anything useful about my ability, but I seem to be learning slowly.
So, last weekend I was out in the Hungarian steppes and we came across are really interesting buzzard (well actually a few, but I’ll try stick to the story).
We had actually stopped to check a flock of geese for a few Red-breasted Goose (Branta ruficollis) that were hanging out in the area, when we scanned a few of the buzzards hanging out in the trees lining the snow-covered steppe. And one just stood out as being really different in structure.
Slowly moving closer we got a better look at the perched buzzard and by this stage were getting rather intrigued.
With some patient, we managed to get close enough to get some flight shots of the buzzard as it circled around, keeping a clean 100m distance from us.
As far as I can tell it is an adult male Rough-legged Buzzard (Buteo lagopus).
EDIT: Dick Forsman had the following to say about this bird:
To your buzzard. It is indeed a Rough-leg, an adult male. Adult males are very different from the other plumages, in being much darker and more heavily patterned. Particularly the underwing coverts are heavily marked, which is a good character against juveniles and adult females. Some appear almost black-and-white, while others, like this one, shows strong rufous colouration. All in all, a rather typical and easy to id. adult male.
Funny just week before last I was searching through my photos hoping to scrape up a half-decent Rough-legged Buzzard photo for my “The REAL snow birds” blog post and then this beauty showed up in my life. But all this had been inspired by Corey post “Snow Birds” in which he had a photo of a juvenile (?) Rough-legged Hawk (Buteo lagopus sanctijohannis).
So this brings me all to my question: is it really a Rough-legged Buzzard or a Rough-legged Hawk? Or, phrased another way, does anyone know or have an idea what came first, the buzzard or the hawk? Or are they both equally divergent from their origin?
Dale Forbes
p.s. all photos taken with a Swarovski STM80 HD spotting scope, TLS 800 and Canon 7D and are copyrighted.
Nice bird. That’s a veeeeeery reddish Roughleg. If it wasn’t for the clearly visible tail band, you’d have difficulties convincing other birders it’s not a Common.
Hi Jochen, ja the prominent reddish colour in the wings really stood out at the time and I would be really interested to hear from anyone who knows buzzards and hawks better if they can say anything more about reddish buzzards as reddish normally makes me think of long-legged and steppe and I have never seen anything like this in rough-legged.
Why not send the pictures to Dick Forsman? I am sure he’ll be interested.
HI Dale, is this bird not a better fit for Steppe Buzzard (vulpinus)? The broad tail band and broad trailing edge to the secondaries should rule out Rough-legged Buzzard and the rufous tones on the underwing coverts would fit better with vulpinus. As Jochen has suggested Dick’s the man!
And I thought our (North American) buteos could be tough…
@Alan: I had the same thoughts, but the head pattern to me is very pro-Roughleg, and the rest fits Roughleg nicely except for the reddish brown tone. The tail pattern looks a bit intermediate, so maybe … it’s a hybrid? Yes, I know, that’s always the sorry excuse we come forward with when we are stuck, but mixed pairs are known from e.g. Norway.
added an edit with Dick’s comments on the bird.
This adds fuel to the discussion surrounding a bird I saw a while ago in Germany:
http://birderhyde.blogspot.com/2011/02/common-or-rough-legged-buzzard.html
I only had short views of it against the sun and immediately said “Roughy”, but the only pic I got was very poor in quality and all other birders I showed it to said they saw nothing that reminded them of Roughleg, and that it was clearly, definitely etc. a Common.
Well, maybe those birders need to take a look at your bird…
My friend and I have sighted a buzzard on our local patch gr NU0347 and it has us both flummoxed.My wife and I saw it on the 12th june 2012
and she commented on how reddish it looked compared to the buzzards we usually get,it was certainly doing a lot of hovering.My friend a bird-watcher of some 50years experience spotted it yesterday 18/06/2012 and remarked that he hadn’t seen a buzzard like it which is why I logged on to this site,could it be a hy-brid?